News Dispatches Oil response ‘like the Three Stooges’

Oil response ‘like the Three Stooges’

E-newsletter -

Oil pollution has replaced overfishing as the major environmental concern facing our oceans, says a well-known commercial fishing captain and author.

With the BP oil well still spewing crude into the Gulf of Mexico, "dangling a hook" seems pretty minor, says Linda Greenlaw.

Dim lights

Click play to hear Soundings' conversation with Greenlaw and see the most recent photos of the oil leak on the Gulf Coast. Mobile users, click here to watch on YouTube.

Greenlaw gained fame as one of the commercial swordfishing captains featured in Sebastian Junger's book "The Perfect Storm" and the 2000 film of the same name. Since then she has written several books and has been featured on the Discovery Channel.

Greenlaw spoke with Soundings while promoting her latest book "Seaworthy: A Swordboat Captain Returns to the Sea" ($25.95, Viking, 2010) at RJ Julia Booksellers in Madison, Conn. The non-fiction hardcover looks at her time swordfishing in Newfoundland's Grand Banks, including a stay in a Canadian jail for drifting across the border.

 

In this issue
Oil response ‘like the Three Stooges’
A U.S. design on the waters of Ireland
Tom Neale’s ICW Log: Part IV
Loran tower comes tumbling down

Comments (6)
6 Wednesday, 09 June 2010 01:38
floridafishfinder
BP, more like the Benny Hill Show. Anyone think of strategically placed implosive devices set at various depths drilled around a much deeper section and let tons of rock and sand seal it? ....just the suggestion of another fisherman ill prepared to deal with an oil spill. Oh, wait a minute, Oil is not my profession. I would be prepared for MY profession if BP was prepared for THEIRS...
5 Tuesday, 08 June 2010 12:31
PKuchuk
I don't understand all the boat owners and captains saying they are waiting for BP to call them to go to work. Why do you need permission to save your livelihood.

If every boat sitting at the dock bought some 55 gallon garbage cans and a bucket to scoop up the oil, they could go out and pick up thousands of gallons a day.

They should take a hint from the people of Nashville and get to work cleaning up without waiting for somebody to cut them a check.

It seems they would rather curse the darkness than light a candle.
4 Tuesday, 08 June 2010 01:16
Scott
It's sad Greenlaw tries to justify that her overfishing is better than what BP is doing because at least she's trying to feed someone. Uh, doesn't she realize BP is feeding her diesel guzzling boat and her gas guzzling truck she drives to her boat? I'm not saying BP is doing the best job, but she can't cover up the damage she does to the environment by pointing fingers at someone else even if they're doing more damage. Come on Soundings, can't you find a better person to talk about the spill???
3 Monday, 07 June 2010 20:33
Howard Waldman
Ask yourselves this: Maybe they want this to go on like it is. Maybe the plan IS to destroy. Maybe the Manchurian President is just doing what he is supposed to do. Its just the next planned step in destroying our wonderful country. And now like Rahm says they are going to take advantage of it. Cap and Trade get 2 industries shut down seafood and oil!!
2 Monday, 07 June 2010 19:41
Bert Browning
I agree!!!!

I think that it is ridiculous that most of the focus is on stopping the leak and not so much on clean-up and prevention efforts. This should be simultaneous efforts. Also, it is overwhelming the amount of ropes to get effective material/products into the hands of the response personnel of each county on watch. My company has a viable, if not the best, solution to absorb all forms of hydrocarbons from oil to sheen. ABSORB, not just contain. As I understand it, no one will buy/use the product because it is not on BP's approved list and therefore, expenses will not be reimbursed. It has been approved by the EPA along with other certifications and prior testing being completed. The information has been submitted to BP and is moving through the stages. However, the next stage is testing by BP. ARE YOU KIDDING??? BP and the federal government are highly involved in evaluating and studying and less on reacting. It is proven and accepted by the EPA, what more do they need to know? This can and is perhaps the best solution to protect the critical habitat and industry found in the Apalachicola bay. Franklin county commission is aware of the product, but will not move forward until BP gives the ok. Centek Industries Inc environmental products.
1 Monday, 07 June 2010 19:22
Alan Lewis
It's too bad that fisherman like Greenlaw and congressmen like Markey, who know nothing about oil rigs, feel they need to grab headlines by criticizing those addressing the oil spill as "three stooges". BP may not be doing everything right, but they surely are better prepared than fishermen to deal with the oil spill. Adm. Thad Allen, who is nobody's stooge, certainly seems to think so.

Add your comment

Your name:
Your email:
Comment (you may use HTML tags here):
  The word for verification. Lowercase letters only with no spaces.
Word verification:
Looking for a great place on the web for new and used boats? Visit us at BoatQuest!