Skip to main content

Owners mourn loss of two classic yachts

Mike Wright and Jody Reynolds were asleep at their home in Syracuse, N.Y., when a knock at the door awakened them at about 4:30 a.m. It was two police officers.

Twenty-six boats were destoyed when McCotters Marina in Washington, N.C., went up in flames.

“I wondered, What have I done now?” says Wright, 64.
The police wanted to know whether the couple owned a boat docked at McCotters Marina in Washington, N.C. Yes, they were storing a boat there for the winter.

It was Hermione, an 86-year-old, 56-foot Elco motoryacht believed to have been the last of 11 of that design built.
“That’s how the news came to us,” Wright says. “It was shocking.”
The wooden Hermione — named for a character in Greek mythology who also is the namesake of the Sicilian queen in Shakespeare’s “The Winter’s Tale” — burned and went to the bottom with 25 other boats in an early morning blaze that swept through a covered dock this winter at the 180-slip marina off the Pamlico River.
The officers wanted to make sure the couple hadn’t been sleeping on the Elco, as they sometimes do when they work on her at the marina. But for the cold weather, Wright says, he might have been there that week. He is a sound sleeper, and the fire engulfed 100 feet of covered dock in less than 10 minutes. One marina liveaboard had to jump into the 37-degree water to escape.
Hermione had no deck hatch aft, where Wright would have slept. “I could have been trapped aboard,” he says.
Firefighters worked the blaze for five hours. Though investigators suspect the fire was electrical in origin, marina owner/operator Mark Henley says the exact cause is “undeterminable,” a matter that remains in dispute.
Henley says all 26 boats are off the bottom. By mid-May, debris had been cleared, and a 32-slip fixed dock with no cover was under construction. Opening was scheduled for midsummer. The rest of the 200-slip marina is doing business as usual.
Two liveaboards suffered burns on their hands and a third — the one who escaped into the water — was treated for hypothermia. There was no loss of life — only boats, several of them classics. Two were one-of-a-kind wooden yachts, lovingly restored, rich in history. One was Hermione; the other was Mercedes III, a 70-foot 1960 Grebe motoryacht.

Hermione, the older of the two, was built in 1925 at Elco’s Bayonne, N.J., yard for two successful vaudevillians — Wright knows of them as “Ruby and Ben” — for $25,000, a princely sum in those days. Subsequent owners included an executive of the glassmaker Corning and electrical engineer Milton Ragsdale, chief of NASA’s mission reliability operations from 1960-1974. He owned her for 35 years, most of that time cruising Chesapeake Bay out of Colonial Beach, Va. Richard Thomas, an attorney for Ashland Oil, was the last owner before Reynolds and Wright.
Sloan Wilson, author of “The Man in the Gray Flannel Suit,” wrote a history of Hermione called “The Talking Boat,” referring to what was then cutting-edge telemetry that allowed Ragsdale to keep tabs on her systems when he was at home in Houston and the boat was in Virginia.
Reynolds and Wright owned her for four years, cruising three times to Florida (Useppa Island) and twice to New York (Thousand Islands) for charter. During her lifetime, she had cruised as far afield as Nova Scotia and Cuba. The couple enjoyed cruising the Intracoastal Waterway on Hermione, stopping at small towns along the way. “When you do it at 8 knots on a beautiful boat, and it’s quiet, and the birds are around, and the dolphin are following you …,” says Reynolds, 63. “We absolutely loved the trip.”
And they enjoyed the attention. “We were mobbed at marinas and boat shows,” she says. “If we had a nickel for every picture taken of this boat, we’d be wealthy.”
Wright, a classic-boat surveyor and delivery captain, and Reynolds, a publicist, had put a lot of sweat equity into Hermione to bring her up to snuff. Wright says the boat was elegant to behold. Her hull — riveted 1-1/2-inch cedar planking over oak frames — was quiet at anchor. With her rebuilt twin Chrysler 318s, she was easy to maneuver. “This boat could turn on a dime and give you 9 cents change,” he says.
She carried original brass controls and was designed so that crew and guests rode close to the water, as if on a sailboat, which was peaceful and calming. “She wasn’t perfect. She was just really nice,” Wright says. “She was a go-boat, not just a show boat. … We just feel so bad she died on our watch.”
Reynolds says Hermione was insured but “not nearly for total value.” Though they were searching hard for another classic, Reynolds and Wright were still boatless this spring.

Image placeholder title
Hermione, a 56-foot Elco motoryacht, was owned by Mike Wright and Jody Reynolds.

Mercedes III
Dallas and Mary Foreman, Mercedes III’s owners, share that sense of loss. “The sad part about it is the history that has been lost,” says Dallas Foreman, 54, a chemist who works at a phosphate mine near Washington, N.C.
Named for the three Mercedes diesels that originally powered her (she later was refitted with Detroit Diesel engines), Mercedes III was built in 1960 by H.C. Grebe & Co. for the Kresge family, founders of the S.S. Kresge five-and-dime chain, the precursor to Kmart.
In search of a long-term restoration project, the Foremans found Mercedes III online. She was on the hard at a yard in West Palm Beach, Fla., with a hole in her hull and few to no prospects for a sale, says Mary Foreman, 47, a nurse at East Carolina University in Greenville.
The boat needed a couple of excited, visionary and energetic angels to fix her up. “The owner said if we would take her, he’d give it to us for a dollar,” she says.
Thus began a 6-1/2-year odyssey to restore the custom yacht to her former glory as an elegant, comfortable cruiser. The Foremans and a few friends who caught the vision they had for an ICW boat for their retirement years invested 12,000 to 14,000 hours — 20 to 30 hours most weekends — refurbishing or replacing just about everything. “For the last
6-1/2 years, that pretty much has been our passion,” says Dallas Foreman.
No travel. No vacations to speak of. They finished the restoration last July and took their first charter — a wedding party — to Ocracoke on the Outer Banks in August.
The Foremans live just 10 miles from McCotters. An emergency services worker — a friend of Dallas’ who knew the couple kept a boat there — alerted them to the blaze shortly after it was reported. “I was hoping it was the marina store [that was on fire],” he says. “We could see the glow in the sky from five miles away, so we knew it was bad.”
Arriving at the marina with an emergency services crew, they passed through the police cordon, and as they neared the docks they saw Mercedes’ bow engulfed in flames. Five months earlier — to the day — the Foremans had stood on the same pier and christened Mercedes. “I was completely and utterly helpless to do anything,” Mary Foreman says. “Words cannot convey how I felt. It still breaks my heart.”
The next day, all they could see of the boat was five feet of charred stem sticking out of the water. “At least we finished it,” Dallas Foreman says. “We can say that, and we got to take a few trips — memorable trips. All we can do now is move on.”
The Foremans salvaged from the charred remains a set of table service and two decorative mermaids — one a brass hook, the other a cast-iron bottle opener.
“I brought some of the ashes home to put in my flower pots,” Mary Foreman says.
The couple carried liability insurance on Mercedes III but no hull coverage. “We were going to get full coverage this spring, as she was scheduled for a pullout and inspection then,” she says.
The Foremans will remember Mercedes as a distinctive boat with panels of stained glass in the doors; a beautifully crafted teak, rosewood and mahogany galley table; and lots and lots of curves. “There’s nary a straight line on these boats,” Dallas says. “They are very curvy. She was a beautiful vessel.”
The Foremans had planned to cruise and charter Mercedes on the ICW full time in their retirement, which is at least 10 years off, and maybe do a Great Loop cruise. “We love the waterfront towns and villages,” Mary Foreman says.
That dream lives on. “We’ve actually been doing some retail therapy,” says Dallas. “We’ve been looking.”
He has owned three other classics: a 1949 Trojan, a 1959 Cadillac and a 1972 Broadwater. He’s eyeing an Elco now.
“I’d like to buy one pretty much done —
essentially completed,” he says.
No more projects — for now.

Image placeholder title
Dallas and Mary Foreman spent 6-1/2 years restoring Mercedes III, a 70-foot 1960 Grebe motoryacht.

This article originally appeared in the July 2011 issue.