The Truth About Survival Training - Soundings Online

The Truth About Survival Training

It shouldn’t be necessary to learn offshore survival tactics if you were schooled on boating safety
Author:
Updated:
Original:
Time in a life raft will make you understand that “survival” is something you want to avoid if at all possible.

Time in a life raft will make you understand that “survival” is something you want to avoid if at all possible.

I get asked all the time about survival at sea. Whenever I give a talk on boating safety, at least one person is interested in life rafts, survival tactics and whether or not I’ve read one book or another about epic survival on the ocean. After I lay down all the ways to stay out of trouble, and how to make sure that help arrives if you do have an emergency, the questions come.

“Could you talk about how to survive in a life raft and what you think about rationing? When should you first start drinking water? Have you ever read Adrift by Steven Callahan?”

Despite my military training in survival (including the extreme ocean type), I rarely find it necessary to discuss open-ocean survival tactics. There are two reasons. One is that if anyone is interested in extreme survival, there are plenty of books to read, and some of them even have good advice (Adrift is one of them). The other reason is that except in infrequent circumstances, the only way to find yourself in an extreme survival situation is to ignore everything else you’ve ever learned about boating safety.

To be clear, if you find yourself alone in a life raft and have no idea if you are going to be rescued, then you’ve really screwed up—at least five different ways.

Despite the hype that long-term sea survival receives on the news, actual long-term survival situations are anomalous. Survival is what happens after you have failed at boating safely. When someone asks about water rationing and what they should do if they need to survive in a life raft, I rephrase the question: “What should you do if you completely blow off everything we know about being safe at sea, make a half dozen rookie mistakes and then end up in a life raft? Well, first, you regret every error you made that got you there, and then hope you are as tough and smart as Steve Callahan.

Callahan was, and is, an extremely competent and safe sailor. He was a victim of his time. When Callahan entered his life raft, it was February 1982. The Cospas-
Sarsat satellites that would have detected his EPIRB wouldn’t be online for another seven months. If Callahan had left Spain’s Canary Islands in 1983, his EPIRB would have been detected, and his book would have been titled something like, Adrift: The Worst 7.6 Hours of My Life.

Having said that, I do have students enter and spend time in a covered life raft. And though I believe I pass along useful information, the primary purpose of the exercise is to help students understand that being in a life raft—a huge win compared to not being in one—is an awful experience to be avoided. Like reading epic survival stories, time in a life raft will make you understand that “survival” is something you want to avoid, if at all possible.

I’ve lost my access to the U.S. Coast Guard database where I first found the following data, but I’m confident it is still accurate: The average time to rescue at sea following a distress call with location data is 4½ hours. You don’t need to take a class on how to ration the water among four people if you’re going to be picked up in time for dinner. You will not be trying to catch fish with your hands, or tackling seabirds that land on your raft, or going mad drinking the seawater. There is enough boating safety stuff to learn without worrying about what to do if none of it works.

Don’t get me wrong: If you go offshore, you should have a life raft, and you should know how to stow it, deploy it and use it in an emergency. You also should know how to behave when you’re in it. Sea survival training is not useless, but stay focused: The smart move is to do everything you can to stay out of the raft in the first place. 

This article originally appeared in the August 2019 issue.

Related

charly-hengen-coast-guard

Why Most Sea Survival Training is Useless

If you find yourself floating in a life raft, you better hope that you are as resourceful, and as smart as, Steve Callahan. Find out why in this week's installment of Mario Vittone's blog Lifelines: Safety And Rescue At Sea.

_USCG-Rescue-2

Hypothermia Myths And The Truth About Cold Water

The dangers of falling overboard are amplified when the water temperature is below 60 degrees. In this week’s Lifelines blog, retired Coast Guard rescue swimmer Mario Vittone talks about four things that can happen to the body in cold water — and dispels a myth or two.

1862081_1800

The World’s Greatest Job

Being a United States Coast Guard Helicopter Rescue Swimmer may just be the best job in the world. Mario Vittone explains what it takes to make the cut.

J73A2702_1800

Survival Made Very Simple

I knew a North Carolina highway patrol officer who once told me, “I’ve never unbuckled a dead man.

Mario-Vittone-recovery

The Truth About Cold Water Recovery

Victims of cold-water immersion aren't out of trouble after being rescued. In his latest installment of Lifelines: Safety And Rescue At Sea, Mario Vittone discusses what to do — and what not to do — when treating someone with hypothermia.

12.27Lifelines.

The Survivor’s New Year’s Resolution

Mario Vittone is resolving to read and learn more in the new year. See what 7 safety and survival books make Vittone’s must-read list in his latest Lifelines: Safety And Rescue At Sea blog. WATCH.

iStock-843856918

The Company You Keep

Mario Vittone says boating with certain people can be a recipe for disaster, so choose your crew carefully.

helicopter-with-diver

The World’s Greatest Job: How Rescue Swimmers Are Made

You don’t have to be able to deadlift 400 pounds, but you do need to be able to keep your cool under pressure if you want to become a Coast Guard helicopter rescue swimmer, writes Mario Vittone in this week’s Lifelines: Safety And Rescue At Sea blog.