EPIRBs Alone Do Not Save Lives - Soundings Online

EPIRBs Alone Do Not Save Lives

Author:
Publish date:
Sailboat

I love EPRIBs. When asked what one thing I would take with me offshore, I always answer: an EPIRB. There is simply no valid argument against these devices. I recommend them to friends, insist on them for family and think anyone who goes to sea without one is just plain stupid.

Now that we’ve cleared that up, here is another thing I believe: EPIRBs cannot save your life. All they can do is tell the rescuers where the EPIRB is — not you, not your boat, not your life raft. If I could remember the number of searches I have been on following an EPIRB activation — where we never found a thing and no one came home — that number would hollow out your soul.

Though they are attributed with saving the lives of over 1,500 mariners per year, in my career I have seen more risky decisions made — many of which ended in tragedy — because an EPIRB was used as a sort of “Easy Button” to reset the game if things went wrong. They can’t. EPIRBs are dangerous when boaters think that having them (alone) is enough.

EPIRBs won’t help you stay warm. You can’t use them to stay afloat. They will not make the ocean a less dangerous place or keep you alive a minute longer if you get into real trouble out there. EPIRBs do not save lives — rescuers do. You should always remember that they are a communications device, and nothing more. Like every other piece of equipment on board, proper use of an EPIRB takes — at least — some time, consideration and effort. And it’s not enough to simply have one aboard — you have to know how to use it.

Proper Registration

Just like your VHF radio, your EPIRB needs to be registered. It's the information in that registration that gives the search and rescue teams some pretty vital information about what they are looking for. And it can include more than just who to call and your vessel's particulars. In fact, if used correctly, your EPIRB registration data can send rescuers your entire float plan.

While the registration allows you to list two emergency contacts, with up to four phone numbers each, the most unused field in EPIRB registrations is the “Additional Data” field. It’s a 500-character space where you can write whatever you want.

Your EPIRB registration can be updated as often as you like with information such as “Leaving 08-12-17 – 0800 - from Apollo Beach, Heading for Dry Tortugas. 4 POB.” (I wish.) Or you can act as your own best emergency contact and provide a link to your float plan.

The image below is from my own EPIRB Registration:

chart

I use the "Additional Data" field to link to my online float plan. If I keep that link updated, it becomes all I really need in my additional data field, and provides searchers the best possible chance of finding me.

You don’t need to have your own website to link to your float plan. You can use Dropbox or Google Drive to simply link to your Word or PDF float plan document and provide everything that might possibly be helpful to searchers. My friend, Behan Gifford, provided an excellent example of a well-considered float plan and EPIRB "Additional Data" field use in her Sample Float Plan.

Proper Use

You might hate hearing this (sorry), but Category I EPIRBs – the kind that automatically release and “float free” from your vessel — do not always automatically release or float free from your vessel. They have to be mounted correctly. What “correctly” is can be a very nuanced thing that depends on vessel type.

When the sailing vessel Cheeky Rafiki went missing in May 2014, the vessel EPIRB was not activated. From the official report: “No alert was received from Cheeki Rafiki’s EPIRB, possibly because it could not be retrieved from inside the vessel following the rapid capsize and consequent inversion after the keel detached from the hull.”

Sailboats tend to capsize and take a long time to sink. The hydrostatic releases that allow EPIRBs to release from their mount will not release until submerged at a certain depth. If mounted inside the cockpit of a sailing vessel (a common thing), hydrostatically released EPIRBS may not get to release depth – ever – and floating free is not possible from the midline of a capsized vessel. I suggest sailors find a way to mount their EPIRBS on the outside of the rail.

Practice Makes Perfect

At sea, in an emergency at night, is no time to be reading the directions. If you haven’t practiced activating your EPIRB, then you will not be good at using it during an emergency. Though you should not actually activate the EPIRB to “test it,” you should inspect and follow testing guidelines for your EPIRB monthly. Guidance on how and when are linked here. If you are not removing the EPIRB from its mount every month, completely, then you are not inspecting your EPIRB. Get on it.

EPIRB test

Remember, an EPIRB won’t save your life — it will only make it much easier for someone else to do that. And let me emphasize, I am not saying EPIRBs are bad. I’m suggesting that perhaps, some of us may be using them incorrectly, with a false sense of confidence.

EPIRBs are a tool of true last resort. Their activation often follows chance after chance to call in for help that might have avoided the dire emergency you’re now facing. Don’t rely on them as the only gear you need to be safe, but do have them aboard and treat them as the vitally important tools they are by updating your registration and checking the condition of your EPIRB, often.

These electronic devices are last-ditch wonder-flares for distressed mariners lost at sea, and for that purpose they are my favorite must-have things aboard any vessel. But they should never be used as a planning tool. They are not to be taken into account when making ANY decisions about what is safe and what isn’t, or about what you can handle and what you can’t. They will not keep you out of trouble. And if you don’t feel safe making the trip without them, then you have no business making the trip at all.

Related

epirb

EPIRBS Alone Do Not Save Lives

I love EPIRBs. When asked what one thing I would take with me offshore, I always answer: an EPIRB.

R2PB3W_1800

Why Go It Alone?

Self-reliance is one thing many boat owners embrace, but that ethos could get you into trouble, writes Mario Vittone. p.p1 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px; text-align: justify; line-height: 11.0px; font: 39.5px 'Meta Serif Pro'} p.p2 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px; text-align: justify; line-height: 11.0px; font: 9.0px 'Meta Serif Pro'} p.p3 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px 0.0px; text-align: justify; text-indent: 8.0px; line-height: 11.0px; font: 9.0px 'Meta Serif Pro'} span.s1 {letter-spacing: 0.6px} span.s2 {letter-spacing: 0.1px} T here was a time when leaving sight of land came with a good chance of never seeing it again. Before the invention of the marine chronometer to determine longitude, going over the horizon was a risky move. Even with accurate charts and a watch, the sea remained deadly; so deadly that the raised platforms known as widow’s walks on New England homes got their name from the sea captains’ wives, who would pace their rooftops, looking seaward for ships that never returned. Without VHF radios or radar, anyone who sailed offshore was truly on his own. Self-reliance wasn’t a romantic, Emersonian notion; it was a condition. Sailors had only themselves. I’ve met countless sailors who do their best to hold on to the traditional notion of being on their own out there. They speak of self-reliance as part of the appeal of being far offshore, alone in the world with only their skill and wits to protect them. They speak of it as a decision they made to be independent. When I was working in search and rescue, these sailors were the ones who always called at the last possible minute; but they always called. These are the guys who often say silly things like, “Never step off until you have to step up.” They were the first ones to send hate mail when I suggested that being alone in a life raft without having made a distress call meant a sailor had screwed up (“The Truth About Survival Training,” August 2019). “What about a lighting strike that causes a fire?” one man complained. “I guess you’ve never heard of anyone hitting a deadhead in the middle of the night,” another offered. Those who fancy themselves to be like the sailors of yore said I was wrong. Self-reliance, they wanted; blame, not so much. Now, I’m no sailor. While I do love boats and have spent a few years working on them, the bulk of my exposure to modern boating has been through search and rescue. For a long time, I was only on boats that were in distress following a call for help. Perhaps that skews me to one side of this argument, but given that experience, I believe this: The idea that you are self-reliant out there can get you killed, while the idea that everything is your fault is vital to your safety. We are connected in ways our great-great-grandfathers could never have imagined. Our radios can talk to each other. Our boats have alarms and pumps connected to apps on phones. We do not watch from rooftops for sails on the horizon; we log on to websites for real-time information. We are not alone out there anymore. But, make mistakes at sea, and you will, one way or another, invite people ashore to join you in your “self-reliant” adventure. We must never lose the sense of absolute personal responsibility for our own safety. There are rare situations where lightning strikes and submerged containers cause unforeseeable situations, but they are no reason to abandon modern tools and procedures. We don’t take off our seat belts just because there is only a slim chance that oncoming traffic may swerve into our lane. The answer to the rare disaster we can’t predict in boating is a float plan and communication prior to the mishap. I think the last great gains to be made in boating safety are in how we think about being on the water. If you still believe in self-reliance, then Godspeed, but keep your VHF radio on, if only so that your loved ones aren’t walking the rooftops, hoping for your return.

iStock-937731582_1800

Not So Fast

Coast Guard Helicopter Rescue Swimmer Mario Vittone says don’t leave the dock too fast; you might endanger the safety of crew.

vittone_front_0802

A Few Pieces Of Paper Could Save Your Life

Retired rescue swimmer Mario Vittone and helicopter pilot Dan Molthen spent countless hours looking for lost boaters, yet neither had ever seen the one document boaters are encouraged to create prior to getting underway: a float plan.

IC-M605

DSC Is An Amazing Tool. Do You Know How To Use It?

At a meeting with 250 boaters last year, I asked for a show of hands: “How many of you have registered your DSC radio and have an MMSI number?

14103922587_033b54b223_k

If You Had to Pick One: EPIRB vs. AIS vs. Satellite Devices

What’s the one man overboard device you should pack in your life jacket? The answer is, “Yes,” writes Mario Vittone in this week’s Lifelines: Safety And Rescue At Sea blog.

mario-vittone-in-water-lifejacket-signaling-device

Simple PFD Rules Could Save Your Life

When people fall overboard, more often than not it’s at the marina when boarding or stepping off the boat.

radio0714

DSC: The radio feature you likely aren’t using

At a meeting with 250 boaters last year, I asked for a show of hands: “How many of you have registered your DSC radio and have an MMSI number?